Most Popular Facilities

Wi-Fi
Free parking
No Pool
Air-conditioned
No Pet-friendly
No Restaurant
No Airport shuttle
No Fitness center

Welcome to Three Judges Motor Lodge

Situated conveniently at 1560 Whalley Ave in New Haven, Connecticut, Three Judges Motor Lodge presents itself as a modest yet practical option for travelers seeking budget accommodations near the city’s attractions. With a rating of 2.7, this motor lodge appeals largely to guests who prioritize affordability and functionality over luxury.

The recently renovated rooms stand out as a positive feature, reflecting the new management’s commitment to improving guest experience. Visitors have noted the cleanliness of the rooms, including bathrooms, and appreciate the fully functional amenities such as air conditioning and reliable Wi-Fi. The accommodations offer a good range of options concerning bed configurations and smoking preferences, catering to individual needs with straightforward simplicity.

Staff friendliness is another highlight. From attentive front desk service to quick problem resolution, guests frequently mention the supportive and approachable nature of the team. The owner’s generosity and hands-on management style add a personal touch that sets a warm, welcoming tone.

While the lodge lacks certain amenities commonly expected in higher-tier hotels—such as a pool, restaurant, airport shuttle, or fitness center—it compensates with two convenient parking lots that allow easy access to rooms and quick access to downtown New Haven’s sights and recreational spots. For travelers using the motel as a base to explore local attractions or pass through the area swiftly, Three Judges Motor Lodge offers a pragmatic solution.

It is important to acknowledge the motel’s simple, no-frills environment. The neighborhood can feel sketchy at night, and the lodge is best suited for transient stays rather than extended luxury stays or family vacations. Nonetheless, for those on a tight budget or needing a reliable place to rest, it delivers decent value and comfort, often exceeding expectations within its price range.

In summary, Three Judges Motor Lodge embraces its role as a functional, economical retreat from the city rush. It’s a place where practicality takes precedence but where genuine hospitality and recent improvements provide guests with a restful and uncomplicated stay.

Room 1
Room 2
Room 3
Room 4
Room 5
Room 6
Room 1
Room 2
Room 3
Room 4
Room 5
Room 6

Great for visitors

Thing to do
Yale University
4.5 stars 2169 Reviews
Storied private Ivy League school founded in 1701 & known for liberal arts, drama & music programs.
Yale University Art Gallery
4.8 stars 3093 Reviews
Museum showcasing art from many regions & centuries housed in a Louis I. Kahn building & others.
Yale Center for British Art
4.7 stars 623 Reviews
Museum designed by Louis I. Kahn housing the largest collection of British art outside the U.K.
Transit
S Genessee & Harper Ave
08 minute
Amity Rd & Fowler St
07 minute
Whalley Ave @ opp Amity Wine Co
02 minute
Airports
John F. Kennedy International Airport
Driving: 01 hour 36 minute | Transit: 03 hour 37 minute
Newark Liberty International Airport
Driving: 01 hour 45 minute | Transit: 04 hour 00 minute
LaGuardia Airport
Driving: 01 hour 23 minute | Transit: 03 hour 01 minute

Last Reviews

Preetham Bangera
06 December 2025

As far as motels go, it was a decent experience. When you ask for a room, you're given options regarding how many beds and smoking preference. I took a two person non smoking room with single king size bed. The room, including bathroom, was clean. The A/C was fully functional and the CRT in the room had an ample amount of channels. There are two parking lots each allowing easy access to the rooms and main office. The people at the front desk are all business but easy to talk to. This motel is right off exit 59 of CT-15.

Gerald Smith
04 December 2025

My experience is and was good Dave and his staff have been really good to me he knows me very well my name is Gerald Smith I last i had room 145 been staying there off and on wish they could rent a room out to a loyal customer i enjoy it there wish i could stay here i recently had room 120 i would love to talk to the owner about renting

Keith Karlac
30 November 2025

Def a cheAp hotel. And the guys working here are pretty cool. I mean it's not the most up to date. But when ur funds r low. This is the spot. Hot showers heat and ac. Work good. This whole lit area is scetchy at night. But other than that not a place to bring wifey but a place to go when u break up. Not that bad. But it's not the Hilton that's forsure but 60 bucks a night u cant complain

MMG's Test
12 November 2025

This place is meant for a quick place to sleep, and it does the job it close to downtown New Haven but no where near in the heart of downtown, all the people in the office are really nice helpful, my key stopped working and they were happy to replace it for me. There are a couple quick places near by and overall does the job its supposed to fulfill, and seemed better than anything close within the area.

dhwani purohit
16 September 2025

The motel is with the new management! Amazing staff, the rooms have been renovated and looks amazing now! The owner is very generous, supportive and smart!

Info (Essential details)

  • Check-In14:00
  • Check Out
    Check-Out11:00
  • Phone
    Phone Number+1 203-389-2161
  • Address1560 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06515, United States